The Sawmill Menu

If you’re wandering through Shaver Lake and stumble upon The Sawmill at 41203 Tollhouse Rd, you’re in for a treat. The menu strikes a balance between hearty comfort food and lighter, veggie-friendly options. From the bar, the Caramelized Burnt Ends are a must-try, rich and smoky, while the Sausage and Brat Board gives you a satisfying mix of flavors perfect for sharing. Their Sawmill Wings, available in a Sweet & Spicy glaze, pack a punch, and the Potato Skins are crispy, loaded with toppings, and utterly addictive.

Moving to the dinner entrees, the offerings feel like a warm hug on a plate. The Pork Chop is tender and seasoned just right, the Fried Chicken hits that perfect crispy-on-the-outside, juicy-on-the-inside note, and the Braised Short Ribs practically melt off the bone. For those craving something simmered low and slow, the Crock section doesn’t disappoint. Elmo’s Chili brings a hearty, spicy kick, Cookhouse Beans are smoky and comforting, and the Crock of the Day adds a surprise twist that keeps the menu feeling fresh.

Vegetarian diners aren’t left out either. The Rice Bowl with Tofu and Sautéed Veggies is wholesome and satisfying, paired nicely with a side of Edamame. The Garden selections round things out, with Caesar, Garden, and House Side Salads providing crisp, fresh flavors that balance the richer dishes beautifully. Overall, The Sawmill’s menu is approachable, diverse, and full of crowd-pleasing favorites that make every visit feel like a casual, yet delicious, culinary adventure.